Sunday, December 18, 2005

 

Merry Christmas

greeting
The important thing is that you say something civil.....
It's a Christian holiday (contraction of holy-day) that due to crass commercialism has become a national phenomenon, a retailer's bonanza as people feel the need to buy each other gifts and spend lots of money on decorations. Hey, I'm not against commercialism, I'm sure it's worth lots of jobs. I'm sure it's good for the economy. It's supposed to be a holy day, celebrating the birth of the world's most famous carpenter, a carpenter who went on to do some amazing things for humanity.

Then again, if you read the biblical account of the birth of Jesus, there are indications that the actual birthday of Christ was probably not on December 25th. Why celbrate on that day? Because the church decided to celebrate on that day. Why did the church choose that day? Probably because it coincided with the pagan festival of the winter solstice. The early church co-opted a lot of pagan stuff in an attempt to draw people to their religion.

I'm not putting down Christmas. It simply doesn't matter when Jesus was born, or what we do to celbrate. I think the important thing is that we celebrate. Another important thing is that we know what we're celebrating.

I'm not anti Santa Claus or any of the commercialism that is associated with Christmas, but I always had a bit of a problem with non-Christians co-opting the Christmas celebration. If Christmas is a Christian holiday, then why do Moslems and Jews get the day off from work as well?

There's a value to all of us celebrating at the same time. Jews celebrate Hannukah, actually a somewhat minor Jewish holiday that has gained importance do to it's temporal proximity to Christmas. Ramadan is at roughly the same time as Christmas. Some professor at Long Beach State University came up with the idea of Kwanzaa, cobbling together Aftican harvest traditions into a celebration specifically for African Americans. Regardless of what the religious right wants you to believe, this time of year is the holiday season.

I celebrate Christmas because I'm a Christian. I realize that not everyone is a Christian and there's really not any value to forcing my particular holiday down anyone's throat. Do I say "Merry Christmas" to people? Of course I do. I've also been known to put up Christmas lights, bring a living tree into my living room and send cards proclaiming my best wishes to the recipient. If someone commits the 'sin' (according to the Christian right) of saying "Happy Holidays" to me, I may respond in kind or I may reply with "Merry Christmas." It just depends on situation.

The Christian right is trying to persuade/force retailers to celebrate Christmas instead of a seasonal holiday. I understand why a company would try to stay nondenomenational as possible this time of year. Namely there are plenty of retail outlets in existance, if they proclaim a "Merry Christmas" they are potentially alienating customers who don't celebrate Christmas. I don't care what store you care to name, this time of year they are more worried about their bottom line than proclaiming their celebration of any specific holiday.

I don't see the value of forcing a Wal-Mart to tell people Merry Christmas. If the Christian right wants to force Wal-Mart to do something, force them to buy American goods, force them to treat their employees fairly and pay them a living wage. Instead of forcing them to put up a Christian facade, force them to act in a Christian manner.

To those on the Christian right, if a clerk at Wal-Mart or Target says "Happy Holidays" to you, don't be offended. They have no idea of your religious beliefs, they can't possibly know and are better off not assuming that you're Christian. As a Christian, though, you can reply with "Merry Christmas." That's your right and there's nothing they're going to do to try to make you say otherwise. Extend them the same courtesy.

BOJ

Comments:
Temporal proximity. Cool. Many Dollars To You!
 
My only problem with this time of year is when one religious or ethnic group lays exclusive claim to the winter solstice and berates all others for their way of celebrating. I think there's room for everyone!!! As a non-Christian person I'm sometimes a little annoyed that they feel they own this time. And I try not to be too smug when I remember that us pagans were here first!!! It's all about marketing, after all. Placing Christ's birth celebration near the winter solstice was the calendar equivalent of opening up a store right across the street from your biggest competition. And it's worked pretty well, 2000 years later Christianity is going strong. And don't get me going on the Easter thing! It's funny how few Christians know how Easter's date is determined every year. It's kinda pagan, if you ask me.
 
Actually, the date of Easter is determined by where the Jewish holiday of Pesach (Passover) falls. The Jewish religion, like Pagan observances, uses a lunar based calendar. The Jews realized that there were slightly more than 12 lunar months in a solar year and use the Vernal Equinox to keep the actual date of Pesach from varying too much.

The 'Passion Week' took place during the week preceding Pesach, Good Friday occuring on the first day of Pesach, Easter occuring at the end of Pesach.

So, yes, Easter does fall on the first Sunday after the first full moon following the Vernal Equinox (I think I got this right), other differences accounted for by when Judaism considers a new day to begin, but the dating method comes more specifically from Judaism than from Paganism (assuming that's a word).

I'm not denying that Christianity lifted a lot of things from Pagan traditions. It did, things like Christmas trees. But for a lot of symbolic reasons, Pesach and Easter are tied.

For more confusion I could go into the dating differences between catholic Easter and Orthodox Easter. I don't completely understand the difference, but I think it has to do with the change from the Julian to Gregorian calendar.
 
But what we all want to know is...were any of these dating methods Intelligently Designed?!?!?!
 
The only intelligently designed dating method is the "automobile".
 
You've gotta have a car if you want to WwtK.
 
Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

The Bert Convey
Principle
Friends' Blogs
My Photo
Name:
Location: United States

I'm not telling you anything...

archives